Review Furious Plunderer
Answer: EASE LEASE PLEASE
Samuel Yeom, Liam Thomas, Alyssa Lee

This is a minimalistic puzzle with an odd title, suggesting that understanding the title is an important step in solving the puzzle. Indeed, we can find a synonym of each word in the title that fits the pattern given by the blanks in the puzzle—to "review" means to RATE, a "furious" person is IRATE, and a "plunderer" is a PIRATE. Upon submitting RATE IRATE PIRATE, the solver is told to "Do it again".

This time, we apply the same transformation to the meta answers—SIMPLICITY means EASE, a CHARTER is a LEASE, and to DELIGHT means to PLEASE. Putting these words together, we get the final answer, which is what the pirates can say to help pay for the convention.